third updated version (*/**/***)
There’s nothing like great music to lift the spirits during times of crisis – though hopefully the coming Christmas season will offer some respite for everyone. And as cd boxes make wonderful gifts, even when pricey (prices here range from £13.75 to £288.00), I thought that pre-Christmas I’d get in early ‘while stocks last’ (as they say). I’ve divided these personally chosen selections into specific categories, to help you identify which ones might be suitable for which friends or relations. Most should be available online (virtually all my choices were released during the course of this year, or thereabouts) and I’ve either reviewed – or will review – quite a few of them in fuller detail for Gramophone magazine.
You can always drop me a line on this blog at robccowan.com if there’s anything else I can at least attempt to help you with. Perhaps post your query as a response to this feature.
All prices are rounded up to an average.
***Richard Bonynge’s ballet bonanza
Fancy indulging in an extremely tuneful tin of Quality Street? Richard Bonynge’s ‘complete ballet recordings’ put together by Australian reissues guru Cyrus Meher-Homji for Decca fit the bill perfectly, 45 cds chockfull of adorable music, including two versions each of Giselle and Coppéla, Sylvia and the three Tchaikovsky ballets, in the case of Swan Lake more complete than most, over three hours’ worth in fact. The beauty of Bonynge’s Swan Lake is its operatic sense of scale (Bonynge the opera conductor would surely have connected with this aspect of the music), the net result being one of the most gripping performances I’ve heard, its cumulative effect quite overwhelming. The playing of the National Philharmonic (a UK orchestra created exclusively for recording purposes, founded by RCA Records producer and conductor Charles Gerhardt and orchestra leader and contractor Sidney Sax) is splendid and Decca’s sound throughout the set (whether analogue or digital) is characteristically sumptuous. Novelties abound, with works by Minkus, Auber, Drigo, Messager and others, including a whole host of rarely heard overtures. Other orchestras featured include the Suisse Romande, the LSO, the English Concert Orchestra and the Orchestra of the Royal Opera House whereas among added instrumental/vocal bonuses are unusual cello concertos beautifully played by Jascha Silberstein. As to the annotations, Paul Westcott writes on the recordings and Mark Pullinger offers concise chapter and verse on the composers and synopses. Would I have anticipated the high pleasure yield experienced? Not on your life! Rarely has being wrong proved such a joy.
Richard Bonynge: complete ballet recordings
Decca (45) 485 0781
***Eduard van Beinum: a rostrum master celebrated
Talk of the Concertgebouw and the two most frequently cited past maestros tend to be Willem Mengelberg (distant) and Bernard Haitink (recent). In between came Eduard van Beinum (1900-1959) whose sizeable discography, both ‘live’ and studio, embraces a wide range of repertoire, from Bach to Bruckner, from Mozart to Mahler and beyond (ie Stravinsky, Kodály, Bartók) all of it performed with flare and understanding. Scribendum’s 40-cd celebration includes sonically compromised but interpretatively electrifying ‘live’ relays of Bruckner 8 and Mahler 6 as well as wartime broadcasts of Tchaikovsky’s Fourth Symphony and Romeo & Juliet Fantasy Overture that rival pre-war recordings under Mengelberg for drama and passion. Van Beinum’s way with French music was, like that of his successor Haitink, celebrated, and two versions of Debussy’s La Mer sine brightly among a plethora of rivals, the earlier (and swifter) of the two a rough-sounding dramatic wartime effort, the more relaxed later version in stereo. Add works by J. S. and J.C. Bach, Handel, Haydn, Beethoven, Mendelssohn, Berlioz, Elgar, Britten, Respighi, Borodin, Sibelius, Schoenberg , Hendrick Andriessen, Thomas, Nicolai, Richard Strauss (an electrifying live Don Juan), Arnold (Beckus the Dandipratt superbly played), Franck, Ravel (including an outstanding stereo La valse), Willem Pijper and so on and you have what is to my knowledge the most generous collection of van Beinum’s recordings so far issued, and on that count alone, is much to be prized.
The Art of Eduard van Beinum
Scribendum (40cds) SC823
*Classic Ravel tracks from the earliest days of recording to 2019
Among Ravel’s most magical creations is his concise and occasionally jazzy ‘lyric fantasy’ L’enfant et les sortilèges, a cautionary but ultimately touching tale about a naughty child who is reprimanded by objects in his room that he has been destroying. The end of the work is a real tear-jerker, so be warned. Warner’s admirable collection includes a vivid 2016 French recording of L’enfant under Mikko Franck, which is followed by performances of other, briefer works under Ravel’s own direction. The riches on offer here are substantial, not least the Daphnis et Chloe under André Cluytens, Sir Simon Rattle conducting the Mother Goose ballet, other orchestral works under the likes of Jean Martinon, Carlo Maria Giulini and Riccardo Muti, piano works with Bertrand Chamayou, Alexandre Tharaud, Samson François and Anne Queffélec and countless rarities. The deal is crowned by superb notes by Ravel expert Roger Nichols.
Ravel: the complete works
Warner Classics (21 cds) 0902952832
FOR FANS OF THE BAROQUE
A winning collection that offers good performances of key Bach orchestral works (Brandenburg Concertos, orchestral Suites, and Violin Concertos), Corelli’s ground-breaking 12 Concerti grossi Op. 6, Handel’s Water/Royal Fireworks Music and first four organ concertos, Vivaldi (including ‘The Four Seasons’), Telemann (selections from ‘Tafelmusik’ or ‘Table Music’) and so forth. While hardly benchmark renditions, this is a reliable and sensibly priced starting point for anyone who fancies the ‘sound’ of baroque music but isn’t, as yet, too fussed about the finer details.
Brilliant Classics (25 cds)
Masters of the German Baroque
Now this really is high quality. Ricercar has over the years issued numerous recordings featuring top-of-the-range early music performers in sound that presents a most beautiful tonal blend. The repertoire featured in this generous anniversary box includes little-known members of the Bach family whose hypnotic works often sound unexpectedly modern (while JSB himself isn’t forgotten), as well as attractive dance music by Michael Praetorius, and compositions by Heinrich Schütz, Dietrich Buxtehüde, and numerous other composers who are very little known outside of specialist Baroque circles. I have personally derived untold hours of pleasure from this collection and would recommend it unreservedly.
Masters of the German Baroque
Ricercar set RC110 (31 cds)
Iona Brown revisits Handel’s Concerti Grossi at the Academy
Decca recently re-released, in the context of their big Academy of St Martin in the Fields anniversary box (485 0093, 60 cds), Iona Brown’s spirited 1979 Philips recordings of Handel’s complete Concerti Grossi Opp. 3 and 6, claiming Op.6 was a first cd reissue though in fact it wasn’t. Now Hänssler Classic offer a bargain box of her later digital recordings with the same band, stylistically very different, less rhythmically pungent and with added woodwind lines. Also, this later set is less ornamental: note the curlicues in the First Concerto’s second movement that have vanished during the intervening years. I’d say that of the two this newer set is more prone to dance; it’s also lighter on its feet, more keenly inflected and rather more in keeping with current performing practices for Baroque music. The sound is excellent.
Handel Concerti grossi Opp. 3 & 6
Academy of St Martin in the Fields, Iona Brown
Hänssler Classic HC17035 (4cds)
FOR LOVERS OF DISTINGUISHED PIANO PLAYING
Andor Foldes: A musician’s virtuoso
Andor Foldes’s style of piano playing is both spontaneous and perfectionist. You might call him a musician’s virtuoso. No-one surely has tapped out the first movement of Beethoven’s Waldstein Sonata with a firmer sense of rhythm or made Bach’s Chromatic Fantasia sound less ostentatiously virtuosic. Foldes’s major achievement on disc is his survey of Bartók’s solo piano works for Deutsche Grammophon, here supplemented by an earlier version of the Sonata and his only recording of the Second Concerto, which is propulsive, powerful and where needs be elegant. His Mozart concerto recordings are often sublime while other Beethoven – virtually half of the sonatas are included – exhibit formidable levels of understanding. Among other highlights are works by Copland and Kodály, including Foldes’s own imaginative piano transcription of excerpts from Kodály’s Háry János Suite
Andor Foldes: the Complete Deutsche Grammphon recordings
Eloquence (19 cds) ELQ4841256
Alexandre Tharaud: from Scarlatti to the Beach Boys
Try Chabrier’s ‘Idylle’, rather like a Frenchified equivalent of a late Brahms miniature, equivocal music, gaily tripping along in its own very private world. The beauty of Tharaud’s approach is that he has the music greeted by countless rainbow hues, the approach both mobile and eventful, quite unlike anyone else’s. There’s charismatic Scarlatti and a most imaginative reworking – Tharaud’s own – of the Adagietto from Mahler’s Fifth. For most of the time you could easily imagine that Mahler’s original is in fact an orchestration of what Tharaud plays here. He also offers us his colour-coded transcription of Debussy’s Prélude à l’après-midi d’un faune, extracts from concertos and numerous modern works from Hans Abrahamsen and a piano piece ‘around the Beach Boys’ to his own Corpus Volubilis. I loved every minute and my advice would be to hide the booklet under the table and listen ‘blind’, just for the fun of it. In that context identification hardly matters, only the music and the wonderful way Tharaud plays it.
Alexandre Tharaud: le poète du piano
Warner Classics (3 cds) 9029518087
The pianist Rose Tamarkin was once married to Emil Gilels, and died in Moscow at the age of 30 almost exactly seventy years ago. According to Wikipedia’s fairly informative article at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosa_Tamarkina ‘Tamarkina started appearing in public at the age of 13, astounding listeners and critics with the maturity of her interpretation, temperament and her virtuosity’. The evidence on disc is unbelievable, most especially the Liszt items (the Rigoletto Paraphrase, Petrarch Sonnet No. 104 and Hungarian Rhapsody No. 10), the Sonnet raging with the full force of that ‘temperament and virtuosity’ As to the opening of Rachmaninov’s Second Concerto, yes, the piano initially drowns out the orchestra but once into its stride the performance proves among the most compelling ever committed to disc. Also included, a warmly phrased and at times heroic account of Franck’s Violin Sonata where Tamarkina partners the expressive Marina Kosolupova and there are performances of the Brahms and Taneyev Piano Quintets with the Bolshoi Theatre Quartet, the Brahms featuring remarkably clean finger work (as well as the first movement’s sizeable exposition repeat). The final disc opens to a Schubert and Schubert-Liszt sequence, two Impromptus from D899 (the E flat pure filigree), and Liszt’s versions of ‘Der Müller und der Bach’ and ‘Erstarrung’, both recorded live, sometimes minutely flawed, but anguished and full of foreboding.
The Art of Rosa Tamarkina
Scribendum Argento SC819 (3 cds)
*Chic Frenchman with a mind of his own
Fifty years ago this month the great French pianist Samson François died at the age of 46, having recorded Debussy for EMI (Warners) on that very morning (22nd October to be exact). François – who the great Alfred Cortot claimed was unteachable – regularly pushed the interpretative boat out, touting novel ideas that would never have occurred to lesser musical minds. This latest ‘complete edition’ includes a first-ever release of a live Nohant recital given just months before the pianist’s death, minutely flawed its true but with an account of Schumann’s mercurial Papillons that is so personal, so exquisitely nuanced that notated fact becomes musical fantasy. Other live recitals are also included, as are near complete traversals of the piano works of Chopin and Debussy and various concertos, one of the most striking being Prokofiev’s acerbic Fifth (the stereo version under Witold Rowicki) where François merely flicks at the second movement, making others (including Sviatoslav Richter) sound bullish. You’re unlikely to agree with everything you hear, but I’d be very surprised if you leave this wonderful set without having experienced some level of inspiration or stimulation. Also included, an interesting DVD ‘Samson François: The Enchanter of the Piano’.
Samson François: Complete Recordings
Warner Classics (54 cds + 1 DVD) 0190295261863
** Duet partner with a style of his own
Mention the pianist Pierre Barbizet and his regular duo partner the ill-fated violinist Christian Ferras inevitably springs to mind: the Barbizet/Ferras partnership made some fabulous records, not least the complete Beethoven violin sonatas (two of them twice recorded) as well as sonatas by Enescu, Debussy, Fauré, Brahms, Franck, Chausson’s Concert and so forth, not forgetting flute sonatas with Jean-Pierre Rampal. As to solo repertoire Barbizet taped a benchmark set of Chabrier’s piano works (including pieces for two pianos and piano, four hands, Barbizet duetting with Jean Hubeau), a trio of crisp and assertive solo Beethoven sonatas, various chamber works (including Berg’s Chamber Concerto with Ferras, under Georges Prêtre) and Serge Nigg’s jazz-romantic hybrid Piano Concerto No. 1 (with André Cluytens conducting). All plus more are included in a desirable boxed set that should yield many hours of musical pleasure.
Pierre Barbizet: the Complete Erato ad HMV Recordings
Erato (14 cds) 0190295187620
***Barenboim plays Beethoven’s sonatas complete third time around
For this latest Barenboim traversal of the sonatas DG facilities a comparison of the Young Turk with the Wise Elder by including, in addition to the main set (recorded this summer), 1958 recordings of selected sonatas where the teenage Barenboim proved his musical mettle – and persuasiveness – with performances that are remarkably assured. One of the sonatas included twice is the life-changing Hammerklavier, late music composed in the isolation of deafness with a slow movement that defies description, Barenboim in youth insightful and attentive whereas his later performance is a broad, serene and emotionally engaging narrative, pure tone poetry from beginning to end. Throughout the cycle Barenboim eases us from sentence to sentence, paragraph to paragraph, less a pianist pure-and-simple than a thoroughgoing musician, landing chords with varieties of attack much as he might with an orchestra, and always with a keen sense of structure. These are deeply pondered performances, less perfect than profound and with the bonus of Beethoven’s greatest piano work – his Diabelli Variations – adding further sustenance to an already rich array of ingredients. Not an ‘only’ set to own perhaps, but certainly one to place beside Artur Schnabel, Richard Goode, Alfred Brendel and Wilhelm Kempff.
Beethoven complete piano sonatas, Diabelli Variations
Daniel Barenboim (piano)
DG (13cds) 483 9320
FOR CHAMBER MUSIC AFICIONADOS
Beethoven complete violin and cello sonatas, plus the two greatest piano trios
For starters, beam up the central section of the third movement from the Piano Trio Op. 70 No. 2 (1:54), where the wittily affected string playing-style apes early music, while Melnikov’s response to it is uncompromisingly firm. Real conversation, this. Furthermore, the tipsily descending piano line at 0:41 is one of the weirdest passages in all of Beethoven. The Archduke Trio and sonatas (Violin and Cello) are memorably played, balletic in the faster music, charged with a symbiotic sense of dialogue elsewhere. While not pretending that Busch, Heifetz, Piatigorsky, the Beaux Arts, the Stern Trio et al are kicked out of court, Melnikov and friends have plenty to teach us and I for one was consistently attentive. Just one minor caveat, a production fault on the last cd might mean a temporary delay in availability.
Beethoven – Isabelle Faust, Jean-Guihen Queyras, Alexander Melnikov
Harmonia mundi HMX (6 cds) 2908873.78
Price not yet available – probably around £35.00
Beethoven captured live around the globe
Quatuor Ébène’s epoch-making ‘Beethoven around the World’ project shared Beethoven’s quartet cycle between seven international venues though you’d never guess from the consistency of the sound. Nor would you guess that they were recorded live and in rehearsal: there’s virtually no evidence of an audience and no applause. As to the performances, we’re talking nose-to-nose confrontation, lacerating attack too, but in Op.132’s sublime slow movement a matchless level of involvement, at least in terms of digital recordings. If Beethoven’s ‘sixteen’ is on your bucket list, use Quatuor Ébène’s compelling reportage to learn the ropes.
Beethoven around the world (the complete string quartets): Quatuor Ébène
Erato (7 cds) 0190295339814
The Smetana Quartet recorded live in Prague 1976-1985 – first Western release
There are times when the Smetana Quartet levels with Quatuor Ébène from brilliance but in general their Prague stereo recordings for Nippon Columbia are less extreme than those of their younger rivals (Op.132’s sublime slow movement clocks in at 16:28 whereas Quatuor Ébène opt for a heavenly 21:00). But tempo isn’t everything and when it comes to refined expression, stylistic appropriateness and the sensitive balancing of parts, ‘rightness’ is a word that frequently springs to mind. The sound too is superb.
Beethoven Quartets complete – the Smetana Quartet
Supraphon (7 cds) SU 4283-2
Russian Chamber Music
The Borodin Quartet (personnel at this stage of their game: Kopelman-Abramenkov-Shebalin-Berlinsky) are handsomely authoritative in a Shostakovich Quartet selection which reaches across Nos. 1, 2, 3, 7, 8, 12 & 15 alongside the Piano Quintet and Second Piano Trio with the formidable Elisabeth Leonskaja, all compellingly performed. Then there’s the complete run of Tchaikovsky quartets and the sunnily affirmative string sextet Souvenir de Florence and Alfred Schnittke’s arrangement of Mahler’s piano quartet, as well as other pieces by Schnittke and works by Stravinsky and Weinberg.
Tchaikovsky, Shostakovich, Schnittke, etc Borodin Quartet, Leonskaja, etc
Warner Classics (8 cds) 0190295204631
FOR FIDDLE FANCIERS
Eloquence’s posthumous celebration of the violin’s Grand Dame includes a first-release VW Lark Ascending under Sir Roger Norrington imbued with great feeling and a passionate 1982 Sibelius Concerto with Zubin Mehta conducting. The bulk of the set however is devoted to a portrait of the artist as a young girl, recordings of mostly short pieces with some concertos added that report Haendel’s youthful combination of tonal sweetness and breath-taking agility. As an expressive virtuoso Ida Haendel was up there with the best of them, and it’s great to have her rarer 78s sounding so smooth.
Ida Haendel: the Decca Legacy
Decca Eloquence (6 cds) 484 1688
c£35.00 – in preparation
* Henryk Szeryng – the ultimate ambassador of great culture
At the outbreak of World War II the great Polish-Mexican violinist Henryk Szeryng (“Szeryng” by the way a Polish transliteration of his Yiddish surname, which nowadays would be spelled “Shering” in the modern Yiddish-to-English transliteration), who was fluent in seven languages, served as liaison officer and interpreter to the premier of the Polish government in exile, Wladyslaw Sikorski. Szeryng died in March 1988, his headstone bearing the concluding bars of the ‘Chaconne’ from Bach’s Partita No.2 for Solo Violin. All this gives some indication of Szerying’s breadth of culture and this SWR collection while not exactly the last word in ‘hi-fi’ presents consistently insightful accounts of concertos by Bach, Beethoven, Berg, Brahms, Lalo, Mozart, Schumann, Sibelius and Szymanowski. If I tell you that the conductors involved include such notables as Paul Sacher, Ernest Bour and Stanislaw Skrowaczewski, you’ll know – or at least guess – that interpretative standards are consistently high. The two Bach concertos are seamlessly played, the Beethoven and Brahms Concertos imbued with a rare sense of musical vision and as for Schumann, Berg and Szymanowski (the Second Concerto), to this day Szeryng has few if any serious rivals. A magnificent set.
Henryk Szeryng: Concertos (the SWR recordings 1956-1984)
SWR Classic (5 cds) 19092CD
Isaac Stern at 100: Sony’s analogue legacy
I’d call him the Marlon Brando of violinists – except he was a contender. Stern was a tough player, his tone sinewy and forthright, his playing heartfelt in every bar. Stern’s analogue legacy is full of glorious things, not least recordings made at the Casals Festival in Prades, especially Brahms’s Second Sextet Op.111, recorded, as I recall, at dead of night and achieving all the impulse of the Third Symphony’s heroic opening. Duo-sonatas with Alexander Zakin and concerto recordings with Eugene Ormandy are also memorable as is Franz Waxman’s Tristan und Isolde Fantasy, a brief but emotional roller coaster. If you’re a fiddle fancier, this one’s worth saving your pennies for.
Isaac Stern: The Complete Columbia Analogue Recordings
Sony Classical (75 cds) 19439724272
Sony Classical marks Itzhak Perlman’s 75th birthday
Few violinists of the last seventy years have proved more productive in the recording studio than Itzhak Perlman. This particular collection includes Perlman’s early Boston Symphony recordings of concertos by Prokofiev (No. 2), Sibelius and Tchaikovsky, all three with Erich Leinsdorf conducting, Lalo’s Symphonie espagnole under André Previn, two discs’ worth of lush film music with John Williams on the rostrum, chamber music and various encore pieces. The playing style is consistently sweet, or brilliant, or both, a workable template for aspiring virtuosos.
Itzhak Perlman te Complete Columbia and RCA Album collection
FOR THE VOCAL CONNOISSEUR
A Belgian seductress sings opera, French melodies and lieder
Among the most erotic of song cycles is Debussy’s Trois chansons de Bilitis, especially the central ‘La chevelure’, a poem about sensual love, which very few singers have managed convey with anything like the requite measure of intensity. One who does is Suzanne Danco whose spellbinding art is celebrated on an 8-cd set that also includes Fauré’s magical cycle La Bonne Chanson and key cycles by Ravel and Berlioz, various arie antiche and lieder by Brahms, Schubert, Mozart, Strauss, Wolf and Schumann – not least Dichterliebe and the Eichendorff set of Liederkreis – as well as various opera excerpts. Danco’s singing combines tonal sweetness, charm, depth of feeling and impressive interpretative intelligence. Andrew Dalton provides excellent annotations.
Suzanne Danco: The Decca Recitals
Decca Eloquence (8 cds) (484 0868)
Soviet Rimsky-Korsakov: great voices and conductors from the Bolshoi in the complete operas plus fragments
Quite a few repertory revelations here and some unforgettable voices (including Andrei Ivanov, Mark Reizen and Ivan Kozlovsky). Mlada is in stereo (under Yevgeny Svetlanov) and includes the sort of ceremonial orchestral writing – more than you’d expect to hear in an opera – that R-K also lavished on Mussorgsky’s Boris Godunov. Among the bonuses is a Tsar Sultan Suite under the maverick baton of Nikolai Golovanov, one of his most memorable recordings – the Suite’s close is especially thrilling. He also conducts two complete operas in the set, May Night and Christmas Eve. Other notable vintage Bolshoi recordings include Mozart and Salieri, Ivan the Terrible, Kaschei the Immortal, The Golden Cockerel, and many others. Variable sound, it’s true, but if you’re after performance authenticity in Russian opera, look no further.
The Complete Operas and Fragments
Hänssler Profil (25 cds) PH 19010
** The Golden Age of British Tenors
Prior to the emergence of Peter Pears, with his distinctive vibrato and perfect diction, British tenors would confide, declaim and sing their hearts out – their individual performing styles (such as they were) regal, princely, heroic and abundantly lyrical. I’m talking such wonderful artists as Heddle Nash, Webster Booth, John McCormack, Walter Widdop, the markedly Italianate Joseph Hislop, Frank Titterton, most of them barely names nowadays, but also singers less familiar even than they were, the likes of Dan Beddoe, Tudor Davies and Hirwen Jones, each conveying heart as well as art, and no two sounding the same. Ward Marston’s superb transfers reach across the years as if time isn’t an issue and the booklet (more a book really) provides a mine of valuable information. An absolute must for the vocal aficionado.
A Survey of British Tenors Before Peter Pears
Marston (3 cds) 53020-2 (www.marstonrecords.com)
c £41.00 ($54)
Rudolf Kempe’s finest Ring
Take Birgit Nilsson as Brünnhilde (or Astrid Varnay in Walküre), Hermann Uhde as Wotan and Hans Hopf as Siegfried with a generally excellent supporting cast and you have the basis of a Ring where thanks to Rudolf Kempe’s sensitively crafted conducting, his knowing way of when to push forwards or draw back, and the lyrical slant of his overall approach, the music’s impact overwhelms you rather than slaps you full in the face (as it does with Solti in Vienna, for all the spectacular impact of Decca’s stereo engineering). There’s an earlier (1957) Kempe Ring from Covent Garden, equally well cast but a good deal less well played and recorded. This 1960 Bayreuth Festival option pips it to the post with relative ease. Wagner expert Michael Tanner offers brief but highly relevant notes.
Wagner: The Ring
Bayreuth Festival (1960), Rudolf Kempe
Pan Classics PC 10418 (12 cds)
Fabulous singing rescued from the mists of time
She was lined up for HMV’s 1930s Hugo Wolf Society but because she was Jewish – and the market was German – she was dropped. Not that Lotte Schoene (1891-1977) was embittered. She soldiered on regardless giving performances notable for their charm, beauty of tone, abundance of feeling and technical brilliance. Marston’s beautifully annotated set features copious opera extracts and lieder, including a 1948 performance of Schumann’s ‘Mondnacht’ that will likely take your breath away. Also well worth noting are Marston collections devoted to the great Russian bass Fyodor Chaliapin (5130-2 [13 cds], $175.00), the incomparable Irish tenor John McCormack (51601-2 [16 CDs], $185.00) and Lotte Lehmann – Vol 1 [acoustic recordings], 54006-2 [4 CDs] $72, and Vol 2, 56004-2 [6 CDs], $72.00, Lehmann, as many will already know, a soprano in a million. Yes, these sets are relatively expensive, but given the level of artistry on offer, and the enormous (ie, successful) work that has gone into making some very old records listenable, they’re worth every penny/cent/euro
The complete Lotte Schoene
Marston (5 cds) 55002-2
FOR DEVOTEES OF GREAT CONDUCTING
***Beethoven symphonies Live at the Concertgebouw
Imagine a quality Strad lying in wait for the magical touch of a master violinist and you’ll have some idea of the effect that RCO Live’s collection of all nine Beethoven symphonies under nine very different conductors (each of whom, bar one [Carlos Kleiber], has recorded the entire cycle in a separate context) has on the listener. To hear the magnificent Royal Concertgebouw respond to the different talents of David Zinman (in No. 1, lean and energetic), Leonard Bernstein (No. 2, majestic and warm-hearted), Nikolaus Harnoncourt (‘Eroica’, filled with light and shade), Herbert Blomstedt (No. 4, emotive but poised), Mariss Jansons (No. 5, driven though never to excess), Sir Roger Norrington (‘Pastoral’, full of fun and affection [and, in ‘the storm’, drama]), Carlos Kleiber (No. 7, with a deliriously dancing ‘scherzo’ but see below*), Philippe Herreweghe (No. 8, punchy and transparent) and Antál Doráti (‘Choral’, reflective of the work’s epic dimension) is to understand the Orchestra’s ability to adapt to whoever is in charge. Past Concertgebouw cycles under Mengelberg, Jochum and Haitink may offer more consistent viewpoints, musically speaking (all are well worth seeking out), but this latest collection, which alternates traditional performances with (swifter) readings that take heed of modern musical scholarship, confirms how a vital rostrum presence can transform the way an orchestra plays.
*And there’s an interesting twist to this happy tale. The uplifting (and uptight) Kleiber Seventh is only available for the disc edition of the set. For the download equivalent, a more loose-limbed Rafael Kubelík steps in as a replacement, less intense than Kleiber (except for the first movement which is especially impactful) but so shapely, playful and spontaneous. I rather prefer it. All the recordings are excellent, and so are the annotations.
RCO/Warner Classics (5) RCO 19005
Doráti conducts Haydn and Mozart on Mercury ‘Living Presence’
Back in the analogue era Decca recorded the complete run of Haydn numbered symphonies (plus extras) with Antál Doráti conducting Philharmonia Hungarica, an orchestra that was first established by Hungarian musicians who had uprooted after Hungary had been invaded by Soviet troops. Less well known perhaps are selected Haydn recordings that Dorati made earlier for the American ‘hi-fi’ Mercury label, some with the same Orchestra, others with the LSO or the Bath Festival Orchestra. These precision tooled readings (of Symphonies 45, 59, 81, 94, 100, 101, 103), spirited though frequently lyrical, are supplemented by various Mozart selections including two versions of the great G minor Symphony, the first fast and furious, recorded in mono with the Minneapolis Symphony, the second, a stereo production with the LSO, far more thoughtful and transparent.
Mozart, Haydn Doráti
Decca Eloquence (4) 484 0385
Schubert to start the day with
Miraculous is the only word for it – this, the earliest of three sets of Schubert’s completed symphonies led by one of the most charismatic and individual conductors of the last 60 years, Nikolaus Harnoncourt cuing Schubert’s eight masterpieces, the Chamber Orchestra of Europe as of July 1988 (then just 7 years old), acutely responsive to their visionary maestro, the strings featherlight, the winds supple and expressive, with taut rhythms never excessively driven, and as for transparency – neither of the conductor’s subsequent cycles (with the Royal Concertgebouw [Warner Classics] and Berlin Philharmonic [DG] Orchestras) quite compares. And there’s that uncanny sense that each musical phrase is relating to what comes next (or what went before), forming a meaningful continuum, an approach that speaks volumes about Schubert’s musical designs. That and Harnoncourt’s sense of period style which in this case is never excessively conspicuous: you sense the rightness of his approach in its very lack of exaggeration. Yes, the relatively abrasive Concertgebouw set is more generous with repeats (ie, for the first movements of the first two symphonies and the finale of the Great C major) and the famously burnished Berlin Phil has its own unique tonal appeal, though there the big C major’s scherzo sports applied ländler-like inflections that won’t be to everyone’s taste. Here though the cliche of hearing the music as if for the first time is fully justified, especially the youthful early symphonies, where the lad remains a lad rather than being frogmarched towards premature adulthood. As to the later works, Harnoncourt captures their scale and vivid sense of mystery. He views the ‘Unfinished’ as perfectly cogent tone poetry that ends on its own terms. You could imagine Harnoncourt saying ‘unfinished? Nonsense. All that needed to be said had already been said.’ So, if pressed to choose a Harnoncourt Schubert symphony cycle this is definitely the one to go for, and it’s extremely well recorded. I sat through it at a single hearing, then immediately started from the beginning again. I suggest you set out with those same enthusiastic intentions. You will be richly rewarded. It’s on and it’ll set you back just £28 or so.
ICA Classics ICAC 5160, (4 cds)
Honesty is the best policy: Michael Gielen conducts Beethoven
Gielen’s Beethoven takes a common-sense interpretative route where although scholarship is respected you can tell there’s an individual driving force in charge. We’re given a complete digital cycle of the symphonies plus alternative versions (the Eroica fares especially well, including a DVD), the C major Mass, overtures and a performance of the ‘Grosse fuge’ where the tone palette is varied to mimic the effect of new music. It’s astonishing. No Missa Solemnis, true – but in case you’re interested there’s a superb Gielen-led recording of that on the Orfeo label (C999201).
Michael Gielen Edition Vol. 9: Beethoven
SWR (9 cds + 1 DVD) SWR19090CD
Modern music pioneer puts Beethoven symphonies in the can
Years ago, there were two conductors who frequently took Beethoven’s metronome markings to heart, Rene Leibowitz and before him that fearless promoter of new music Hermann Scherchen. DG’s bargain reissue of Scherchen’s Beethoven recordings for the Westminster label includes all nine symphonies with the Royal Philharmonic and Vienna State Opera Orchestras, some performances super-urgent (the RPO Fifth for example, or the stereo re-makes of 3 and 6), others taking a rather more conventional course tempo-wise. Scherchen gives terrific performances of various overtures and also included are the ‘Grosse fuge’ and Wellington’s Victory (in very vivid stereo). Not for the feint hearted, but certainly a shot of adrenalin.
Beethoven symphonies, etc Hermann Scherchen
DG (8 cds) 4838163
Mahler as he might have heard himself
Hans Rosbaud gives you Mahler both ways. He’ll play up the storminess of the Fifth Symphony’s second movement while the Fourth, although profoundly affecting, is never touched by exaggeration. The Ninth’s first movement might be the fastest – and most intense – on record whereas the grim reaper element of No.6 is realised with nobility rather than exaggerated rhetoric. Das Lied von der Erde features tenor Ernst Haefliger in especially fresh voice and there’s the Seventh, Mahler’s stream-of-consciousness’ symphony, the one that’s all invention rather than all emotion, and absolutely Rosbaud’s bag. The 50s mono sound is perfectly adequate.
Mahler Symphonies Nos. 1, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 9, Das Lied von der Erde
Hans Rosbaud in Cologne and Baden-Baden
SWR Classic (8 cds) (M) SWR19099CD
Barenboim’s Staatskapelle Berlin Bruckner: third time lucky
Daniel Barenboim has recorded Bruckner’s symphonies three times, first in Chicago (DG), then with the Berlin Phil (Teldec) and now, ‘live’, with Staatskapelle Berlin, taped in Vienna (Nos. 1-3, 2012) ad Berlin (Nos. 4-9, 2010), again for. DG. My attention was first drawn to the Fifth, a magnificent performance, in the context of DG’s Staatskapelle Berlin collection and immediately went online to order this Bruckner set (which I have to admit I didn’t even realise existed). I wasn’t disappointed, especially by Symphonies Nos. 4-9 where although the earlier versions are extremely fine, these live revisits have a naturalness about them, a sense of grandeur, an all-embracing breadth of vision that really do elevate them above most digital rivals, Barenboim’s own included. Furthermore, the playing is quite magnificent. The recordings, which are technically first-rate, are available either on cd (the way I have them) or as downloads.
Bruckner Symphonies Nos. 1-9
DG 479 6985 (9 cds)
Charismatic Dutch rostrum master emerges from the shadows
Try van Kempen’s take on Tchaikovsky’s Capriccio Italien, re-orchestrated to spectacular effect while the speed-up at the end finds the Concertgebouw Orchestra racing hell-for-leather yet holding the pace with ease. Then there are Tchaikovsky’s 5th and 6th Symphonies, not dissimilar to electrifying readings by the Orchestra’s reigning maestro for 50-odd years Willem Mengelberg, the 5th especially. Marvellous Beethoven and Reger, too. Like Mengelberg after the War, Van Kempen was accused of collaborating with the Nazis which makes the sessions with the Netherlands Radio Philharmonic of Alexandre Tansman’s moving commemoration of the Shoah and tribute to the founding of the State of Israel, his ‘Isiah the Prophet’ (1950), doubly surprising – and very good to have.
Paul van Kempen Concertgebouw, Berlin sessions etc
Decca (10 cds) Eloquence 484 0237
*A benchmark set of Franz Schmidt’s four symphonies
The first recording of a major orchestral work by the Austro-Hungarian composer Franz Schmidt to really hit the headlines was Zubin Mehta’s superb Vienna Philharmonic version (for Decca) of the composer’s grieving tribute to his daughter, his orchestral masterpiece in fact, his Fourth Symphony. Complete recordings of all four symphonies under, for example, Schmidt’s pupil Ľudovít Rajter, and Neeme Järvi, are now joined by a consistently compelling cycle by the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra under Neeme’s son Paavo, who drives the Fourth with maximum ardour but also realises the Third’s Schubertian axis (the slow movement is especially magical) and the very different characters of the First and Second Symphonies. The First in particular opens like a hymn to the sun, the best version I’ve ever heard. Schmidt was an accomplished instrumentalist, praised to the skies as a pianist by the legendary Leopold Godowsky while Mahler regularly chose him for orchestral cello solos when he (Schmidt) was with the Vienna Philharmonic. The music is of genuinely high quality, imbued with a sense of nature – you could say looking towards the mountains from the metropolis whereas Mahler looks towards the metropolis from the mountains. The set also includes the popular Intermezzo from Schmidt’s opera ‘Notre Dame’.
Franz Schmidt: Complete Symphonies
DG (3 cds) 483 8336
Glorious John: the complete Warner Classics legacy
It’s all here – everything that Sir John Barbirolli recorded for the Warner Classics group, with various orchestras, though mostly with the Hallé. And in case you don’t realise what ‘everything’ implies, we’re talking old records of orchestral opera potpourris, accompaniments for great singers (Schorr, Melchior, Turner, Widdop and so on), collaborations with such masters of the bow as Jascha Heifetz and Mischa Elman, pianists of the calibre of Rubinstein and Alfred Cortot, English music (including the celebrated ‘late’ stereo recordings of Elgar and Vaughan Williams), French music, Mahler (not least songs with Dame Janet Baker), Schoenberg and lighter fare such as Suppé Overtures, all of it performed with considerable flair. There’s also affecting spoken material – including Vaughan Williams presenting JB with the Royal Philharmonic Society medal – and so much more that to list it all would be to monopolise this entire column. It’s my reissue of the year.
Sir John Barbirolli: The Complete Warner Recordings
Warner Classics (109 cds) 0190295386085
The soul of Elgar’s Cello Concerto
For most people of a certain age the mere mention of Elgar’s Cello Concerto means Jacqueline du Pré, one of two versions of the work included in Warners’ Barbirolli box. But for me the version that Pablo Casals recorded with the BBC Symphony Orchestra under Sir Adrian Boult in 1945 delivers levels of pathos, defiance and inwardness that no other version on disc can quite rival. Where du Pré offers a candid confessional, Casals allows us a peep at his very soul, with Boult keeping a firm hand on the tiller. It’s the most wonderful performance most recently presented in the context of a 5-cd Casals set on the Biddulph label which also includes four versions of Kol Nidre – all very unalike – more concertos, and a whole host of sweet morceaux, some in dusty acoustic (ie horn-recorded) sound but all beautifully played. Biddulph have also brought out two of the ultimate antidotes to all those tiresome viola jokes, excellent collections devoted to the legendary viola players Lionel Tertis (LAB3057, 3 cds) and William Primrose (LAB2058, 3 cds), the latter being especially lovely to listen to.
Pablo Casals: Victor recordings; Complete Acoustic recordings; HMV Concerto recordings
Biddulph LAB 5059 (5 cds)
Epic Russian symphony cycle played with conviction
And from Yevgeny Svetlanov an invaluable ‘limited edition’ package of all 27 Myaskovsky symphonies plus a handful of shorter works. There’s so much to savour from this ‘father of the Soviet Symphony’ as he was sometimes known. The Fourth, for example, which opens to a mournful solo flute line before a more tempestuous mood sets in. And tell me is there much other Russian orchestral music of the period (we’re talking 1918) that’s as deeply affecting as the beginning of the Largo second movement? The cycle starts in 1908 (the First Symphony, revised in 1921) and reaches its conclusion in 1949, a year before the composer’s death. It’s the sort of repertoire that can hold you captive for hours such is the quality of the music and Svetlanov’s compelling brand of interpretation.
Myaskovsky Symphonies 1-27, Svetlanov
Alto (14cds) ALC 3141
A SPECIAL ONE-OFF FOR REPERTORY EXPLORERS
Polish music in the 20th century
A journey to another galaxy, albeit one clearly reflected on terra firma. The period covered is 1918 to 2018. It’s the inspired work of Polskie Wydawnictwo Muzyczne (PWM), established in 1945, principally for publishing scores and books on music but of late cds have also joined their agenda. In this context musical pioneers such as Karol Szymanowski, Ludomir Rogowski, Eugeniusz Morawski and Szymon Laks (scores by the last two are especially gripping) reach through the ages to the likes of Lutosławski (who also conducts), Wojciech Kilar, Penderecki, Górecki, Tadeusz Baird and Grażyna Bacewicz with works ranging from full-scale symphonies to Passion settings by Pawel Mykietyn (St Mark), Krzysztof Knittel (St Matthew) and Penderecki (St Luke). Poland was always at the forefront of the post-war avant-garde and this incredible set offers inspired evidence. Yes, the set is pricey and it’s also bulky. In addition to the 36 cds, there’s a book of recordings and biographies, ten separate volumes on each of the decades dealt with and Danuta Gwizdalanka’s valuable 280-page ‘One Hundred Years of Polish Music History’. Performance standards are extremely high throughout and the same goes for sound quality – many of the featured recordings are fairly recent. Poland’s musical legacy is famous for its kaleidoscopic range of colours, and for those eager to enter the inner sanctum of their own musical imaginations this is without doubt a gift in a million, well worth spending those lockdown savings on – either for you or for someone special.
100 For 100 – 100 Musical Decades of Freedom (36cds)
… AND FOR THOSE WHO’D RATHER NOT STAY TOO SERIOUS DURING THE FESTIVE SEASON
Film music fiddler takes to the rostrum
Father of the highly gifted conductor Leonard Slatkin, Felix sung a sweet fiddle on film soundtracks and was leader of the legendary Hollywood String Quartet. And he could certainly train an orchestra, inspiring results that compared with the best that America had on offer at the time – and believe me that was mightily good. This fine-sounding box contains a plethora of showpieces (including an account of Gaité Parisienne that has never been bettered) and, more unexpectedly, some extremely sensitive Delius.
The Art of Felix Slatkin
Scribendum (13 discs) SC822
Crossing over in style
‘Sock-it-to-me’ vintage Hollywood-style hi-fi sonics, some of it recorded in London and a range of repertoire that embraces Elgar, Tchaikovsky, Glazunov, Elgar, Addinsell, Wildman, Bath, an extended tone poem based on The Volga Boatmen and a Cole Porter programme where the song So in Love takes on the epic grandeur of a Rachmaninov symphony. Fabulous playing throughout but no annotation
The Art of Carmen Dragon
Scribendum (17 discs) SC820
Tristan on the tiles
Some years ago, I chanced up a French EMI double CD album that featured the two-piano and solo recordings of pianists Jean Wiéner and Clément Doucet. It included Doucet’s deliciously camp – some would say outrageous – Isoldina, a sort of stride/foxtrot hybrid where the ecstatic climax of Isolde’s ‘Liebestod’ is thrown off like a flirtatious giggle. Over time I’ve scored many laughs with this track and recently, just by accident, I discovered that in 2013 EMI Classics released the complete Wiéner/Doucet legacy from the 1920s and 1930s on four cds where supporting artists include Maurice Chevalier, Jean, Mireille and Germaine Sablon, and Yvonne Vallée. Other classical masters ‘tweaked’ include Grieg, Liszt, Chopin, Dvorák, Johann Strauss and more Wagner. Gershwin is very well represented, as are Jerome Kern, and Cole Porter. There are even super-cool versions of Love for Sale and Saint Louis Blues played by Wiéner on the harpsichord – and a very musical ‘straight’ complete account of Mozart’s Sonata for two pianos K.448, plus Bach.
Les Années Folles
EMI France 50999 725703 2 6
15 thoughts on “The joy of choosing ‘classical’ boxed sets as Christmas gifts – a personal selection ahead of time (with brief comments)”
A very interesting post. I see some of your suggestions as possible presents to myself. I did pick up the Les Années Folles box after reading one of your earlier posts, and it is huge fun. Many thanks for the shout.
Fortunately or sadly, depending on one’s perspective, I seem to have accumulated multiple versions of favourite works: I am too easily tempted to buy yet another Beethoven symphony cycle or Schubert String Quintet. Re the former, the Gielen cycle arrived last week. I have so far listened to the first 3 symphonies. Initial impressions are positive. The performances are relatively swift, but still seem ‘phrased’ and not relentless.
I am going to be cheeky and ask you, if you could only take let’s say 9 complete Beethoven cycles and 4-5 Schubert String Quintet recordings to a proverbial desert island, which ones might you select?
With best wishes and hoping that you are remaining safe and sane in these difficult times,
Thanks Lawrence. BEETHOVEN FIRST
Toscanini NBC (1939, Naxos)
Bernstein NYPO, (Sony)
Blomstedt (Straatskapelle Dresden, Brilliant)
Szell, Cleveland (Sony)
Bruggen, Age of Enlightenment (Glossa)
Bruno Walter, NYPO (Sony mono)
Bruno Walter, Columbia SO (Sony stereo)
Klemperer, Philharmonia (Warners – stereo, with 1950s mono versions added)
Gielen, SWR Baden Banden (SWR, or EMI)
AND SCHUBERT … …
Heifetz-Piatigorsky (fast I know, but wonderfully expressive – RCA)
Casals, Stern, etc (Sony – possibly a best ever)
Rostropovich, Tanayev Quartet (Melodiya – Tully Potter put me onto this … very slow second movement. Not for every day but profoundly moving (I didn’t like it at first)
Amadeus, William Pleeth (DG)
Julliard Quartet, Bernard Greenhouse (Sony)
You keep well, too
Thanks for the summary, Rob. The Ida Haendel set looks yummy although she was greatly under-recorded. Actually, I’ve amassed a fair number of her live recordings and they demonstrate what a fearless player she was in person. Her risks didn’t always come off but with such commitment, who cares?! My beloved is giving me the Stern set for Christmas so there will be a lot of violin music playing at chez Roy.
A question. Does anyone ever see boxed sets as an investment? I accidentally ended up with two sets of the Heifetz edition and sold one on a well known auction site for three times what I paid for it!
A good question Rob. I think RCA’s Chicago/Fritz Reiner set is another case where you would likely earn three times what you paid for it – others too. It’s difficult to tell what the ‘earners’ would be but it applies just as much to certain single discs, while others remain worth very little. Best and thanks for writing. Rob.
Your suggestions are very interesting and I want to investigate some of them.
From my own collection, I would want to save Wand’s, Krivine’s and one of Mackerras’ Beethoven cycles for my desert island. For the Schubert, I have and do like Heifetz’s recording, but my favourite historical version is the Hollywood Qt with Reher. There seem to be so many fine modern versions. The Belcea Qt and Erben start the Adagio with a marvellously hushed poise and Janine Jansen and friends are wonderful players who blend well whilst retaining their personalities.
All the best,
Couldn’t quibble with any of those choices Lawrence, especially the two Beethoven cycles. Reher was one hell of a cellist – do try his Don Quixote with the LAPO under Mehta. Fabulous!
Wonderful and eclectic selection, Rob, many thanks. One question: Is the Smetana Beethoven cycle on Supraphon the same one that appeared on Denon many years back in the early CD era? Please advise, because I own the Denon set. Thanks so much for all you do for music! xoxoxo
Thanks so much John. I think it must be the same. It was recorded for the Japanese Nippon Columbia label (this is its first release outside of Japan in fact), recorded between 1976 and 1985. Very best. Rob.
For quite a few years I have been following your articles in the Gramophone (as soon as I open it, I go straight to Replay) and your radio broadcasts, which were a never-ending source of information and enjoyment. I was therefore dismayed to learn of your departure from the BBC some time ago, and even more dismayed at the latest news that Classic FM have decided, for reasons that escape my comprehension, not to renew the contract of their finest broadcaster. The outlook for classical music broadcasting in this country looks very bleak now. I have often thought of writing to you to express my personal gratitude for all the pleasure you have given me, and my only regret is that I was finally motivated to do so by this tragic news. I am sure that there are many people who share my opinion of your marvellous work, but have not found the right moment to express their gratitude and encouragement. On behalf of all your many, many supporters and admirers, I urge you to continue your important work, despite the obstacles that may be placed in your way by the philistine tribe. Shame on them! And all the very best to you, Rob! Keep it up!
Btw. I am a bit old fashioned and not used to communicating with a blog. I seem to remember that on your Saturday night program on Classic FM, you mentioned an email where people can write to you. Does that still exist?
Thank you so much Alan for troubling to write and for your appreciative words. They mean a great deal. As you may well have guessed this is heart-and-soul work for me but the outlets available are diminishing by the day. Radio seems to crave an affable middle ground, ‘the bland leading the bland’ I call it (though to be fair there are exceptions) and although there are some good classical websites and Gramophone still flies its banner high, it’s up to individuals to sort out ways to communicate via sites like this. Don’t blame the presenters, or even the producers. Directives seem to be issued from on high by people who think that cheeky, waggish, happy-clappy presentation attracts people to concert music, which of course it doesn’t. After all, watch, say, the Antiques Road Show where so many of the guests are young and they’re lapping up the opinions of older experts. Age-ism is a real problem, being serious too, using musical terms (even allegro is deemed double-Dutch in some quarters) and as for getting excited over comparisons, which in reality is like making love to the same partner in fifty different ways (if you get my drift), forget it. Anyway I’m trying to get some ideas together and when I do you’ll be among the first to know. Best wishes and thanks again. Rob.
ps My Classic FM email has been withdrawn. Best to post any comments here.
I’ve just come across your blog and would like to join Alan Woods in thanking you for your great contribution to the enjoyment of classical music, and for the pleasure we’ve derived from your broadcast and writings. To put it crudely, I don’t doubt that your departure from the BBC and Classic FM can safely be ascribed to their itch to dumb down. This was obvious as soon as you were obliged to play selected highlights and excerpts instead of whole works on Essential Classics, for example I remember my disbelief that we were only to hear Nimrod I think it was, from the Enigma Variations. I think you also had to drop that brilliant quiz in which listeners had to work out what piece was being played backwards. A clear target for the anti-elitists running the BBC. At least we still have the benefit of your columns in Gramophone, and long may they continue. Your knowledge of music and its recorded history must be hard to equal, and I’ve lost count of the number of CD’s I have bought and enjoyed on the basis of your recommendation. So there are still folk out there who appreciate what you do! All the best.
Thank you so much Tony. That means a great deal. I miss presenting my own choices of recordings, or should I say sharing them, which was such fun, and made me many online friends. But as you say at least I can keep writing and there’s this blog which I enjoy. By the way I’m due to appear on Record Review on the 17th reviewing the Decca Arthur Grumiaux set, so if you’re around …. very best. Rob.
Thanks for the heads-up, Rob. That’s 74 discs I believe. What a wonderful feast, it deserves a whole programme to itself!
Re my query about Eva Bernathova
I mistyped my own name. D’oh!
That’s great to hear, Rob. I’m so tempted by that Grumiaux set but it would entail a LOT of duplication.
And Tony Norgate hits the nail right on the head!